Next Video: How to Make 5-Ingredient Monster Cookie Bars Video Cancel View Recipe: Key Lime Pie Thumbprints This feature is not available with your current cookie settings. You can update your privacy settings to enable this content. Please enable all cookies to use this feature. How to Make Key Lime Pie Thumbprints Video View Recipe: Key Lime Pie Thumbprints Having to choose between pie or cookies is just cruel. With these tart thumbprint cookies, you get all the flavors of Key lime pie that you love in an easy-to-make sugar cookie form. What honestly could be better? Dessert Recipes By Pillsbury