Easy Butterfinger™ Pie
(function() {
document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
var componentMetadata = JSON.parse('\x7b\x22componentName\x22\x3a\x22RatingAndReviewCounts_e8af84a8-5198-47ca-bc1c-daf22247ecf7\x22,\x22deferOptions\x22\x3a\x7b\x22deferComponent\x22\x3afalse,\x22deferType\x22\x3a\x22None\x22,\x22deferId\x22\x3a\x22rf03892b1e0b840d08556db82338f75db\x22,\x22deferredContainerId\x22\x3a\x22\x2fmain\x2frdpRatingAndReview\x22,\x22deferredContainerView\x22\x3anull\x7d,\x22viewName\x22\x3a\x22RatingAndReviewCounts\x22\x7d');
var configuration = {};
var moduleName = 'ratingAndReviewCounts';
var isVueModule = false;
GeneralMills.PandoSites.RegisterControlInstance(moduleName, configuration, componentMetadata, isVueModule)
});
})();
Dorothy Kern
Updated Apr 21, 2021
An over-the-top ode to your favorite candy bar can be yours with a handful of simple ingredients and a few minutes of prep.
Easy Butterfinger™ Pie
(function() {
document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
var componentMetadata = JSON.parse('\x7b\x22componentName\x22\x3a\x22RatingAndReviewCounts_e8af84a8-5198-47ca-bc1c-daf22247ecf7\x22,\x22deferOptions\x22\x3a\x7b\x22deferComponent\x22\x3afalse,\x22deferType\x22\x3a\x22None\x22,\x22deferId\x22\x3a\x22rf03892b1e0b840d08556db82338f75db\x22,\x22deferredContainerId\x22\x3a\x22\x2fmain\x2frdpRatingAndReview\x22,\x22deferredContainerView\x22\x3anull\x7d,\x22viewName\x22\x3a\x22RatingAndReviewCounts\x22\x7d');
var configuration = {};
var moduleName = 'ratingAndReviewCounts';
var isVueModule = false;
GeneralMills.PandoSites.RegisterControlInstance(moduleName, configuration, componentMetadata, isVueModule)
});
})();
- Prep Time 30 min
- Total 2 hr 0 min
- Ingredients 6
- Servings 8
Ingredients
- 1 crust from 1 box (14.1 oz) refrigerated Pillsbury™ Pie Crusts (2 Count), softened as directed on box
- 4 oz cream cheese, softened
- 1/3 cup creamy peanut butter
- 1/2 cup sugar
- 1 1/2 containers (8 oz each) frozen whipped topping, thawed
- 2 cups chopped Butterfinger™ candy bars
Instructions
-
Step1Heat oven to 450° F.
![]()
-
Step2Unroll 1 Pillsbury™ refrigerated pie crust in ungreased 9-inch pie plate. Flute edges as desired; prick bottom and side with fork. Bake 10 to 12 minutes or until light brown. Cool completely.
![]()
-
Step3In large bowl, beat 4 oz softened cream cheese, 1/3 cup creamy peanut butter and 1/2 cup sugar with electric mixer on medium speed until smooth.
![]()
-
Step4Carefully fold in 1 container (8 oz) frozen (thawed) whipped topping. Stir in 1 1/2 cups chopped Butterfinger™ candy bars.
![]()
-
Step5Spread mixture in pie crust. Spread 1/2 container (8-oz size) frozen (thawed) whipped topping over top; sprinkle with 1/2 cup chopped Butterfinger™ candy bars. Refrigerate pie 1 hour before serving.
-
Step6Store loosely covered in refrigerator.
Nutrition
750
Calories
40g
Total Fat
8g
Protein
89g
Total Carbohydrate
44g
Sugars
Nutrition Facts
Serving Size: 1 Serving
- Calories
- 750
- Calories from Fat
- 360
- Total Fat
- 40g
- 62%
- Saturated Fat
- 21g
- 103%
- Trans Fat
- 0g
- Cholesterol
- 25mg
- 9%
- Sodium
- 490mg
- 20%
- Potassium
- 200mg
- 6%
- Total Carbohydrate
- 89g
- 30%
- Dietary Fiber
- 2g
- 10%
- Sugars
- 44g
- Protein
- 8g
% Daily Value*:
- Vitamin A
- 4%
- 4%
- Vitamin C
- 0%
- 0%
- Calcium
- 4%
- 4%
- Iron
- 4%
- 4%
Exchanges:
1 1/2 Starch; 0 Fruit; 4 1/2 Other Carbohydrate; 0 Skim Milk; 0 Low-Fat Milk; 0 Milk; 0 Vegetable; 0 Very Lean Meat; 0 Lean Meat; 1/2 High-Fat Meat; 7 Fat;Carbohydrate Choice
6Recipe Tips
{{tipItemHeadingFormat.replace('{0}',props.index + 1)}}
(function() {
document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
var componentMetadata = JSON.parse('\x7b\x22componentName\x22\x3a\x22RelatedContent_cf68421f-a017-4b99-8f4a-ac3517f06a8c\x22,\x22deferOptions\x22\x3a\x7b\x22deferComponent\x22\x3afalse,\x22deferType\x22\x3a\x22None\x22,\x22deferId\x22\x3a\x22r5ec1a26071ab45ceb0c7b6e8b59d1b00\x22,\x22deferredContainerId\x22\x3a\x22\x2fmain\x2frdpRelatedContent1_NonDeferred\x22,\x22deferredContainerView\x22\x3anull\x7d,\x22viewName\x22\x3a\x22RelatedContent\x22\x7d');
var configuration = {"dataSourceId":"cf68421f-a017-4b99-8f4a-ac3517f06a8c","isCurrentUserAnonymous":true,"isAnonymousUserWithFavorites":false,"relatedContentList":{"contentId":"e328174f-f4a0-4dea-9706-0adc87223d86","listSettings":{"pageSize":3,"startPage":1,"listType":1,"title":"Try These Next","useModalRegistration":false,"regAction":"","esrcCode":0,"favoriteButtonLabelFormat":"Add {0} to favorites","contentTypes":["Category"],"showImages":false,"imageSize":0,"showRatings":false,"allowFavoriting":false,"cssClassName":"relatedContentWithoutImages","favoriteButtonText":""},"items":[{"contentId":"3d3c27ea-1152-46a0-b270-2852f13cf221","contentType":"Category","title":"Peanut Butter Pie Recipes","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/dish-type/pies/peanut-butter","numberOfRatings":"0","averageRating":"0","averageRatingStars":"0","smallImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/mile-high-peanut-butter-brownie-pie_hero.jpg?W=276","mediumImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/mile-high-peanut-butter-brownie-pie_hero.jpg?W=680"},{"contentId":"f07cc7d0-e5ee-4454-823f-28084ee02f27","contentType":"Category","title":"Peanut Butter Cookie Recipes","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/dish-type/cookies/peanut-butter","numberOfRatings":"0","averageRating":"0","averageRatingStars":"0","smallImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/jumbo-honey-roasted-peanut-butter-sandwich-cookies_hero.jpg?W=276","mediumImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/jumbo-honey-roasted-peanut-butter-sandwich-cookies_hero.jpg?W=680"},{"contentId":"d3d94d30-3581-4f57-b44e-b59b4bebd3e6","contentType":"Category","title":"Peanut Butter + Chocolate Cookie Recipes","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/dish-type/cookies/peanut-butter/peanut-butter-chocolate","numberOfRatings":"0","averageRating":"0","averageRatingStars":"0","smallImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/peanut-butter-cup-secret-center-cookies_hero.jpg?W=276","mediumImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/peanut-butter-cup-secret-center-cookies_hero.jpg?W=680"}],"availableItems":[{"contentId":"3d3c27ea-1152-46a0-b270-2852f13cf221","contentType":"Category","title":"Peanut Butter Pie Recipes","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/dish-type/pies/peanut-butter","numberOfRatings":"0","averageRating":"0","averageRatingStars":"0","smallImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/mile-high-peanut-butter-brownie-pie_hero.jpg?W=276","mediumImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/mile-high-peanut-butter-brownie-pie_hero.jpg?W=680"},{"contentId":"f07cc7d0-e5ee-4454-823f-28084ee02f27","contentType":"Category","title":"Peanut Butter Cookie Recipes","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/dish-type/cookies/peanut-butter","numberOfRatings":"0","averageRating":"0","averageRatingStars":"0","smallImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/jumbo-honey-roasted-peanut-butter-sandwich-cookies_hero.jpg?W=276","mediumImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/jumbo-honey-roasted-peanut-butter-sandwich-cookies_hero.jpg?W=680"},{"contentId":"d3d94d30-3581-4f57-b44e-b59b4bebd3e6","contentType":"Category","title":"Peanut Butter + Chocolate Cookie Recipes","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/dish-type/cookies/peanut-butter/peanut-butter-chocolate","numberOfRatings":"0","averageRating":"0","averageRatingStars":"0","smallImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/peanut-butter-cup-secret-center-cookies_hero.jpg?W=276","mediumImageUrl":"/-/media/GMI/Core-Sites/PB/PB/Images/recipes-hero/desserts/peanut-butter-cup-secret-center-cookies_hero.jpg?W=680"}]}};
var moduleName = 'relatedContent';
var isVueModule = true;
GeneralMills.PandoSites.RegisterControlInstance(moduleName, configuration, componentMetadata, isVueModule)
});
})();
(function() {
document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', function() {
var componentMetadata = JSON.parse('\x7b\x22componentName\x22\x3a\x22RelatedContent_cebd36f5-50c3-4ced-bf49-b20dc8574946\x22,\x22deferOptions\x22\x3a\x7b\x22deferComponent\x22\x3atrue,\x22deferType\x22\x3a\x22OnDemand\x22,\x22deferId\x22\x3a\x22r668008f50aae4462bf252634731fc6e9\x22,\x22deferredContainerId\x22\x3a\x22\x2fmain\x2frdpRelatedContent1\x22,\x22deferredContainerView\x22\x3a\x22RecipeDetailRedesign\x22\x7d,\x22viewName\x22\x3a\x22RelatedContent\x22\x7d');
var configuration = {"dataSourceId":"cebd36f5-50c3-4ced-bf49-b20dc8574946","isCurrentUserAnonymous":true,"isAnonymousUserWithFavorites":false,"relatedContentList":{"contentId":"e328174f-f4a0-4dea-9706-0adc87223d86","listSettings":{"pageSize":6,"startPage":1,"listType":1,"title":"","useModalRegistration":false,"regAction":"","esrcCode":0,"favoriteButtonLabelFormat":"Add {0} to favorites","contentTypes":[],"showImages":true,"imageSize":1,"showRatings":true,"allowFavoriting":true,"cssClassName":"","favoriteButtonText":"Save"},"items":[{"contentId":"31a60645-012a-468b-8051-a650c91b9b1b","contentType":"Recipe","title":"REESE’S Peanut Butter Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/reeses-peanut-butter-pie/31a60645-012a-468b-8051-a650c91b9b1b","numberOfRatings":"37","averageRating":"100","averageRatingStars":"5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/ylmdyJhobEiCgrEtanz7zw_webp_base.webp?v=8492b7d1\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/ylmdyJhobEiCgrEtanz7zw_webp_base.webp?v=8492b7d1\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"b8ba2ff5-4e06-426e-ab28-8496f253c116","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Salted Caramel-Chocolate-Peanut Butter Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/salted-caramel-chocolate-peanut-butter-pie/b8ba2ff5-4e06-426e-ab28-8496f253c116","numberOfRatings":"67","averageRating":"60","averageRatingStars":"3","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/Sid8RwDJ206lmxqMebFqAw_webp_base.webp?v=578a837e\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/Sid8RwDJ206lmxqMebFqAw_webp_base.webp?v=578a837e\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"130ce878-8ffe-4cd4-a3c5-d3dd4722df47","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Candy Bar Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/candy-bar-pie/130ce878-8ffe-4cd4-a3c5-d3dd4722df47","numberOfRatings":"2","averageRating":"100","averageRatingStars":"5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/jSivhwW1bk2uWeMNV-YNfw_webp_base.webp?v=63a71da3\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/jSivhwW1bk2uWeMNV-YNfw_webp_base.webp?v=63a71da3\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"961892c7-4026-431f-820c-891f4a10f10c","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Easy Peanut Butter Blossoms","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/easy-peanut-butter-blossoms/961892c7-4026-431f-820c-891f4a10f10c","numberOfRatings":"3","averageRating":"100","averageRatingStars":"5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/guxN0VzABkOwOypb5PN5gw_webp_base.webp?v=c2030b95\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/guxN0VzABkOwOypb5PN5gw_webp_base.webp?v=c2030b95\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"cb7fc678-70ea-44bf-8c90-30070ffca735","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Snickers™ Slab Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/snickers-slab-pie/cb7fc678-70ea-44bf-8c90-30070ffca735","numberOfRatings":"14","averageRating":"70","averageRatingStars":"3.5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/vFJRCuCfU0KrMSsY6P9Icw_webp_base.webp?v=a9607cd3\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/vFJRCuCfU0KrMSsY6P9Icw_webp_base.webp?v=a9607cd3\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"47efd987-44a2-4719-ac6f-73fae361dfe3","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Easy 5-Ingredient Monster Cookies","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/easy-5-ingredient-monster-cookies/47efd987-44a2-4719-ac6f-73fae361dfe3","numberOfRatings":"14","averageRating":"90","averageRatingStars":"4.5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/NMDdS_9kZkKYYmgCHK1Ynw_webp_base.webp?v=b8dc63b0\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/NMDdS_9kZkKYYmgCHK1Ynw_webp_base.webp?v=b8dc63b0\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"}],"availableItems":[{"contentId":"31a60645-012a-468b-8051-a650c91b9b1b","contentType":"Recipe","title":"REESE’S Peanut Butter Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/reeses-peanut-butter-pie/31a60645-012a-468b-8051-a650c91b9b1b","numberOfRatings":"37","averageRating":"100","averageRatingStars":"5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/ylmdyJhobEiCgrEtanz7zw_webp_base.webp?v=8492b7d1\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/ylmdyJhobEiCgrEtanz7zw_webp_base.webp?v=8492b7d1\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"b8ba2ff5-4e06-426e-ab28-8496f253c116","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Salted Caramel-Chocolate-Peanut Butter Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/salted-caramel-chocolate-peanut-butter-pie/b8ba2ff5-4e06-426e-ab28-8496f253c116","numberOfRatings":"67","averageRating":"60","averageRatingStars":"3","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/Sid8RwDJ206lmxqMebFqAw_webp_base.webp?v=578a837e\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/Sid8RwDJ206lmxqMebFqAw_webp_base.webp?v=578a837e\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"130ce878-8ffe-4cd4-a3c5-d3dd4722df47","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Candy Bar Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/candy-bar-pie/130ce878-8ffe-4cd4-a3c5-d3dd4722df47","numberOfRatings":"2","averageRating":"100","averageRatingStars":"5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/jSivhwW1bk2uWeMNV-YNfw_webp_base.webp?v=63a71da3\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/jSivhwW1bk2uWeMNV-YNfw_webp_base.webp?v=63a71da3\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"961892c7-4026-431f-820c-891f4a10f10c","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Easy Peanut Butter Blossoms","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/easy-peanut-butter-blossoms/961892c7-4026-431f-820c-891f4a10f10c","numberOfRatings":"3","averageRating":"100","averageRatingStars":"5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/guxN0VzABkOwOypb5PN5gw_webp_base.webp?v=c2030b95\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/guxN0VzABkOwOypb5PN5gw_webp_base.webp?v=c2030b95\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"cb7fc678-70ea-44bf-8c90-30070ffca735","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Snickers™ Slab Pie","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/snickers-slab-pie/cb7fc678-70ea-44bf-8c90-30070ffca735","numberOfRatings":"14","averageRating":"70","averageRatingStars":"3.5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/vFJRCuCfU0KrMSsY6P9Icw_webp_base.webp?v=a9607cd3\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/vFJRCuCfU0KrMSsY6P9Icw_webp_base.webp?v=a9607cd3\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"},{"contentId":"47efd987-44a2-4719-ac6f-73fae361dfe3","contentType":"Recipe","title":"Easy 5-Ingredient Monster Cookies","isFavorite":false,"linkUrl":"/recipes/easy-5-ingredient-monster-cookies/47efd987-44a2-4719-ac6f-73fae361dfe3","numberOfRatings":"14","averageRating":"90","averageRatingStars":"4.5","smallImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/NMDdS_9kZkKYYmgCHK1Ynw_webp_base.webp?v=b8dc63b0\u0026t=67e847e026fb43aa8d6e3f5ef39a4ef7","mediumImageUrl":"//mojo.generalmills.com/api/public/content/NMDdS_9kZkKYYmgCHK1Ynw_webp_base.webp?v=b8dc63b0\u0026t=3653fe2f5ecd4a47a5a51c97e429947c"}]}};
var moduleName = 'relatedContent';
var isVueModule = true;
GeneralMills.PandoSites.RegisterControlInstance(moduleName, configuration, componentMetadata, isVueModule)
});
})();
- Trademarks referred to herein are the properties of their respective owners.
© 2025 ®/TM General Mills All Rights Reserved