Reviews

Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookie-Stuffed Pies

Take the current craze for cookie-stuffed cookies to hand-held pies stuffed with your favorite cookies. It's one of Top 10 Pies to Try!

Prep Time: 10 Min

Total Time: 25 Min

User Rating (16)

Full StarFull StarFull StarHalf Starempty Star
user avatar
pinklady89 said: report Posted: 1/31/2013 11:32:14 PM
You do not have to make these if you dont like the fat and calorie count. Look somewhere else if your not happy about it.
user avatar
JMNDad said: report Posted: 12/31/2012 10:01:38 AM
Gandksmom - You should realize that it's not "one cookie." It's a pie. Each one has 1/8th of a package of pie dough in it, just like a plain old slice of apple or cherry pie. A quick glance at the picture might fool you into thinking "cookie," but that's deceptive. It's much more like a turnover, and with that in mind, the calorie and fat content isn't really that bad at all. I tried with raspberry jam, by the way. AWESOME.
user avatar
slosh29 said: report Posted: 11/24/2012 4:15:18 AM
I wish Pillsbury would provide a comment board for those who continually complain about nutritional information, ingredient lists, fat and sodium comments and everything else when they obviously have not tried the recipe, or make it clear they have no intention to.I read these to see how others like them, not personal opinion or dietary restriction. I tried these and they turned out well..I used grape jelly as that is all i had on hand but strawberry was requested next time...these turned out to be a great treat, which after all is what dessert is supposed to be.
user avatar
gandksmom said: report Posted: 9/12/2012 9:34:33 AM
I wish Pillsbury would invest in making some healthier recipes. 480 calories in one cookie and 22 grams of fat?! I'd rather eat a steak if I'm going to consume that much! So many of the recipes are just impractical nutritionally. :(
user avatar
younglite said: report Posted: 4/28/2012 5:16:41 PM
Has anyone tried these with grape jelly instead of strawberry? My kids don't like strawberry, but love grape! Just wondering if the grape jelly would melt too much??? Sounds yummy though!! :)
user avatar
LHenry962 said: report Posted: 2/16/2012 10:12:34 AM
Although these sound okay..I am not a big fan of sweets..I think I am going to make a pulled pork filling and make mini sandwiches out of these...let you know how they turn out..
user avatar
jenglish305 said: report Posted: 9/2/2011 12:09:13 AM
Simple recipe, but even so, not worth the time. In addition to the peanut butter and strawberry version, I tried chocolate cookie dough and raspberry jelly. Still not impressed. Won't try again.
user avatar
like2cookluv2eat said: report Posted: 7/29/2011 1:40:10 PM
These were delicious and easy however since I only found the simply cookies I used those. I made them before reading stephie's review and she is right, mine were probably overfilled because they oozed all over but cooled hard enough to still be takeable. I used raspberry too...great minds think alike they were tartly sweetly delicious that way!
user avatar
stephie9802 said: report Posted: 7/28/2011 4:08:14 PM
This was super easy and tasted great! I used strawberry jelly on half the pies and raspberry preserves on half the pies. I liked the way the tartness from the raspberry balanced out the sweetness from the peanut butter cookie better than the strawberry. be careful not to overfill the cookie or the pit top will burst and the jelly/preserves will ooze out.