Search Pillsbury
Search

Three-ingredient chocolate and peanut butter cookies in colors customizable for any holiday! What’s not to love? Blogger Erin Leach of One Particular Kitchen shares a favorite recipe for Holiday Peanut Butter Surprise Cookies.

Prep Time: 10 Min

Total Time: 30 Min

Makes: 16 servings (1 cookie each)

Recipe
Tips (0)
Reviews (0)
RECIPE TOOLBOX

INGREDIENTS

1
 roll (16.5 oz) Pillsbury® refrigerated peanut butter cookies
48
 red and green candy-coated chocolate candies
 Red sugar
 Green sugar

DIRECTIONS

1 Heat oven to 350°F. Line cookie sheets with cooking parchment paper. 2 Remove wrapper from dough; divide dough evenly into 16 portions. For each portion, place 3 chocolate candies in center, forming dough into ball around chocolate candies. 3 On separate plates, sprinkle sugars; roll 8 balls in each color. Place balls 2 inches apart on parchment-lined cookie sheet (do not flatten balls). 4 Bake about 15 minutes or until golden brown. Cool 2 minutes; remove from cookie sheets to cooling racks. Store in airtight container.
This is a great project for kids! They’ll love forming the dough around the chocolate candies and working with the colored sugar.
These cookies are perfect for a festive get-together or tailgate party. Customize the colors of the sugar for any holiday or team.
Colored sugar is found in the baking aisle at the grocery store baking aisle. It can also be easily made by stirring a couple drops of food coloring into 1/4 cup of granulated sugar.

High Altitude (3500-6500 ft)

Nutritional Information

Nutrition Information:

1 Serving (1 Serving)

You can be the first of our members to weigh in on this recipe!

You can be the first of our members to weigh in on this recipe!

What People Are Saying

User Rating (0) empty starempty starempty starempty starempty star

You can be the first of our members to weigh in on this recipe!

Write a Review

Would you make it again?  yes | no

Advertisement

Save Money on Your Favorite Brands

SAVE 60¢
when you buy ONE BOX Original Cheerios® cereal (the one in the yellow box)
SAVE 60¢
when you buy ONE BOX Reese’s® Puffs® cereal
SAVE 60¢ ON TWO
when you buy TWO BOXES any flavor/variety Betty Crocker® Fruit Shapes, Fruit by the Foot®, Fruit Gushers® ...

In the Community

Latest Activity

Contribute to the Community!

Learn More | Sign Up | Login
Advertisement
X
Report Abuse
Log In / Register
No thanks
Tell Us What You Think
Share with us any thoughts, tips, comments, or anything else you have to add to this recipe.
Your Tip: (600 character limit)
Submitting submitting...
cancel
Sorry, we have detected some problems with this form. Please revise
Review This Recipe
Your Review: (600 character limit)
Rate this Recipe
(Click a star to select)
empty starempty starempty starempty starempty star
Submitting submitting...
cancel
Sorry, we have detected some problems with this form. Please revise.
My Pillsbury
 
Follow Pillsbury: